Thursday, August 17, 2017

Like many of you, I'm still sifting through my emotions over what happened this weekend in Virginia. I am angry and sad and confused and lost. Looking for some sort of hope to latch onto, I posted on Facebook that the driver of the car was arrested and denied bail and that one of the "protesters" lost his job. I know my friends are sad and I wanted to offer something encouraging. I've seen others do the same, especially during our TN session of congress. There were posts about hate bill and health care bills that were killed or voted against. It helped us to feel like we were making a difference.

What I didn't expect at all, and what completely blindsided me, was for a member of the burlesque community to call me out on it. What the fuck?? I can't offer some sliver of hope?? She is a woman of color and insisted that I was spreading dangerous rhetoric, that my intention and attitude was wrong. So, immediately, I was defensive. I was told to do some research. And it all totally confused me. I've read books, I've watched films, I've been to and participated in discussions with women of color. Last year I attended a BLM vigil and studied up on how I should behave to be supportive while letting it be about black people and not white allies. I thought, what else can I do??

In my anger and frustration, I allowed the incident to escalate. My friends stepped in to try to defend me. My white ally friends chastised me, at least in my eyes at the time. I thought why even try when nothing I do is good enough??

For two days I felt a rock in my stomach. I questioned why I felt so bad and so angry if I hadn't done anything wrong. I reread comments and posts. On the second day I apologized for half of what I said. I sent a message to the woman who had called me out, trying to explain my viewpoint, my history, how I cared. And I apologized. I thought, okay, that should do it. Because I'm a good person. I do care. If someone can't see that, what else can I do?

And the rock remained in the pit of my stomach. Something was still bothering me. There was a shame I couldn't get past and I couldn't figure out where it was coming from.

Last night I watched this video. I watched a black woman scream from terror and disbelief and emotional pain and distress. I saw a black man insisting that they didn't want that group in their town, in his town, in his home. I saw waves of white people filled with hate, claiming they were fulfilling their rightful part of history.

And I got it. And fuck, it hurt.

Posting that bills are voted down is not equivalent to trying to find anything good from this past weekend. Hey, one KKK was arrested. Yippee!!! Hey, look how all of those white men can push against a line of police and nothing happens to them!! Look how those men are allowed to carry torches and firearms and how our fucking president excuses it all. Gee, that's progress.

No, I was wrong. I didn't want to be. But this wasn't the time to rally and talk about  how things are going to get better. Not when, right now, they are getting so much worse. People of color are truly terrified by what is happening. Because it isn't new. It never has been for them. And now we have a "leader" who all but endorses it. I try to understand, but I can't really fathom what it feels like to walk through life being hated by such a large group of one's own country.

I don't know how this will end. I know how I want it to end. I thought we were better than all of this. I didn't really think we would elect a misogynistic, racist, completely ignorant buffoon for a president. But we did. I didn't think KKK and neo-Nazi groups would organize. Or militarize themselves. But they have. I keep thinking it will stop. This nightmare will end. But it doesn't. I think, okay, we've reached the tipping point. And another wave hits us.

I don't have any answers. I think I have suggestions, but at this point, I'm not even sure about that. But here they are, for whatever they're worth.

White people - don't include POC in your frustrations. They're not here to make you feel better. They don't have to explain their history. Talk to your white friends. Tell them how you feel sad that you try and you feel misunderstood and then try again. It's okay to be angry, we're all angry. But be appropriately angry.

White friends - be patient with each other. Daily conversations of racism haven't been a regular daily activity for a lot of us. I lived in a town for 22 years where I literally went MONTHS without seeing a black person. There were hispanics and latinos, but it was much less diverse than Nashville. If someone isn't getting it, it's helpful to offer different reasoning rather than getting defensive yourself. And if you're not capable of that in the moment, if you don't have the mental or emotional energy, save it for later. We need each other and we need understanding. Am I full of shit on that one? I could be. Like I said, I don't know anymore.

If you have an interaction that leaves you feeling less than okay, explore that feeling. Dig down. Your gut and your heart know what's off, so listen to them. Be humble.

I want to say that hate won't win, but damn. It's got a really fucking good lead right now.

2 comments:

DJ - silverhawk615@gmail.com said...

This one really struck a chord with me. Pardon the essay I may end up writing in this comment. It will almost be worth it; I think.

The ultimate problem here is, in my humble opinion, anger. Whether misplaced or otherwise, we all have some level of anger - anger towards white people for past transgressions, anger at white supremacists for their message of hate, anger by white supremacists over a perceived loss of control of the country, anger because we want to help but don't know what to do, or even anger at how someone chooses to try and help.

Even beyond that, there is "nuance." A simple word, with a simple meaning, that I would argue 99% of the population doesn't understand in a practical way. Not everything is black and white. I'm disgusted with myself for using that cliche, but I didn't have an alternative in the chamber.

I firmly believe that because of the aforementioned anger, it clouds many of our minds, and we are subsequently unable to discuss hot button issues like race with any clarity. If Facebook is any indicator, we aren't conversing in an effort to understand the perspective of others, but lying in wait until they say something we disagree with...and then verbally pouncing.

For the white supremacists among us, I can't offer them much solace.

For the rest of us, I think white people have to understand that black people have a lot of pent up aggression over race relations and sometimes we will lash out unintentionally or unnecessarily, even at those who genuinely want to make things better. It's like dating someone who's been hurt a lot in the past - they want things to work out for certain, but past traumas have predisposed them to certain thoughts/ideas and they may lash out or not know how to handle your attempts at helping them move past it.

For us, black people, we have to afford white people the same notion we want afforded to us - no race of people is a monolith. Not all white people are racist or looking to say something racially insensitive. They may not always know how to phrase their well-intentioned thoughts, but lashing out won't help the situation either.

On the one hand, part of me believes that racism will never end. Humans are by nature, a tribal animal. And everyone wants to establish their tribe as better. Whether it be short people vs tall, skinny people vs fat, white vs black, etc. I think there will always be those people among us who feel that they're in an eternal competition that they MUST win rather than just...being.

On the other, I feel as though, evil always has to be met with resistance. Preferably non-violent, but resistance nonetheless. I think ignorance has to be met with intelligence so the folly of that mindset can be put on full display for the world to see.

I feel myself drifting towards writing about 10 more paragraphs and you didn't ask for a novel so I'll stop here.

Yours is definitely my favorite blog.

Kat said...

Yours are definitely my favorite comments. ;)

I would love to hear more about what you think. I find myself tip-toeing around the subject when I want to talk about how I feel but fear I will offend someone or, worse, have someone tell me that my feelings are "wrong" because racism is over. What??

Please, feel free to leave any feedback you have at any time.

 
The Martini Chronicles. Design by Exotic Mommie. Illustraion By DaPino